European Sovereign Debt – After Ireland
Last updated: 11:28 08 Dec 2010 AEDT, First published: 12:28 08 Dec 2010 AEDT
Signs of contagion spreading across debt markets in Europe led by Ireland instilled setoff jitters around the world. Yielding to pressure from European counter parts Ireland agreed to accept a bail out package from the European Union. Similar concerns have engulfed Portugal and Spain. European Debt markets are likely to leave a sour note over the coming few weeks. Flight to safety may further propel precious metals to end 2010 at a record high.
European economies, it appears, are yet to be out of the woods.
On the heels of Greek sovereign debt woes last year, Ireland is now showing deep cracks in its banking sector. Early signs of these cracks were covered in September 2008 when the Irish government guaranteed liabilities of all Irish Banks. Dodgy loan books by banks in a faltering economy can hardly be saved by guarantees issued by a weak government.
Yielding to severe pressure from the European Union, the Irish government’s decided to accept €85 billion emergency bail-out package to help salvage its ailing banking sector, from the €750 billion emergency loan package established by the EU/IMF duo in May. The parallel agreement gives Dublin until 2015 to bring its budget deficit under control.
The bail out may provide some temporary respite but neither Ireland nor Europe is still out of the woods. Spreads of Irish, Portuguese and Spanish government bonds over those of German bonds continued to widen even after the announcement indicating investors’ scepticism. Spreads have fallen marginally since then with Portuguese bond yield spread versus German debt at 323 bps, and equivalent Irish bond spreads at 565 bps as of December 3.
It may prove to be an uphill task for Irish economy to claw its way back to prosperity. Among EU members, Ireland has the highest loans to deposit ratio followed by Portugal, Greece and Spain. A high loan to deposit ratio in a wavering economy with doubtful loans offer little confidence. It is particularly dangerous when investors move capital out of the country seeking safer economies, as it hampers the country’s ability to sustain its debt.

Ireland also has one of the highest loans to GDP ratios. The €85 billion rescue package requires Ireland to implement austerity measures such as spending cuts, tax hikes and sharply reduced welfare programmes are expected to take priority. Passing the December budget with these measures may however prove to be difficult for a largely unpopular, Brian Cowen, the Irish Prime Minister. Having lost the support of a key coalition ally in the Green Party, Mr Cowen has an uphill task in securing the necessary votes to pass the budget.

While Ireland is indeed a worry, Spain poses the greater concern in the EU. Should the Spanish economy falter, the original €750 billion European Financial Stability Facility may prove to be inadequate. With unemployment rate running at 20% and savings banks (Cajas) relatively undercapitalised, the Spanish banking system remains less than impressive and may need some bailing out.
A closer look at the loan exposure by Cajas indicates that they remain heavily exposed to residential mortgages. Given the depressed status of the Spanish property market, this causes considerable concern and rekindles the memories of the US regional banks few years ago. High unemployment rate further makes these loans increasingly worrying.

Attempts by the European Union and respective governments may wade off banking woes but the European economy appears to be in the doldrums, save few isolated cases. Growing uncertainty may prompt investors to seek the safety of gold and other precious metals thus pushing commodity prices even further. Year 2010 may end with a sour note for European debt but it may mark a remarkable year for gold and precious metals.